coup2k.com
gorewon2000.net
JOIN THE RESISTANCE
New Recruits Click-> HERE
WELCOME, MR. PRESIDENT
Al Gore Click -> HERE
BUSH FAN ESCAPE HATCH
Conservatives Click->HERE

   BUSH BROTHERS BANANA REPUBLIC RESISTANCE, NEWS, HUMOR AND COMMENTARY

MARCHING ORDERS
SATURDAY - JUNE 16, 2001

AN OPEN LETTER TO AUTHOR ANTHONY LEWIS:
"The Closed Mind," or "The Mercenary Mind?"

SITE NAVIGATOR

TO:
Anthony Lewis
The New York Times
229 W. 43 Street,
New York NY 10036

Phone: 212-556-1234
Fax: 212-556-3690

email: letters@nytimes.com

June 16, 2001

Dear Mr. Lewis:

First, allow me to say that I am a longtime admirer.  I've read two of your books, "Gideon's Trumpet" and "Make No Law," and am a fan of both.  And when you titled one of your New York Times columns "The Feeling of a Coup," I jumped with joy to see a respected journalist use that word at all -- even if it was in a metaphorical context -- since so many in the media refuse to even acknowledge the extraordinary political terrain on which the nation's highest appellate court (I no longer call it the "Supreme" anything) has stranded us all.

But Mr. Lewis, I have to tell you that your most recent column, "The Closed Mind," struck me as either highly disingenuous, highly satirical, or highly misinformed.

In your column you express frustration that Mr. Bush can believe in something that lacks any scientific support (the workability of space-based antiballistic missile defense systems), while refusing to believe in something with a strong scientific foundation (global warming caused by greenhouse gases).

You framed your discussion of his policies in term of Bush's beliefs.

You describe Mr. Bush as, "a man of strong opinions stubbornly held, in defiance of reason:"

"What President Bush has been telling European leaders this week can be readily summed up: I am not going to do anything about global warming because it needs more scientific study. But I am going to act urgently to develop a missile defense system although none have any proven scientific basis and every test so far has failed." - Anthony Lewis, "The Closed Mind." The New York Times, June 16, 2001

There has been much written and spoken about the man's proud lack of intellectual curiosity -- a fancy way of saying he doesn't care, doesn't know, and doesn't care to know -- so why would you imply that his policies are informed by scientific passions? 

Mr. Lewis, do you really believe that Bush's environmental and defense policies have anything to do with his "deeply-held" beliefs on these subjects and their relative scientific merits?  I cannot believe that you do.

To even the most casual observer, science (or the lack thereof) is not the common denominator when it comes to Bush's policies on these issues.

Money is.

I needn't tell you who benefits from these two Bush policies -- a quick trip to opensecrets.org, "Your Guide to Money in American Elections," will make that clear. 

Bush's refusal to protect our environment from a scientifically established threat, while at the same time pushing forward with a costly and scientifically unsound missile defense system (a provocative move that violates treaties America freely signed), is not a matter of his personal scientific stubbornness, or a matter of honest disagreement about the relative scientific merits of either.

It is not even an indication of Bush's disrespect for our environment, or his disrespect for our nation's credibility in the international community.

It is about the only Republican ethic that really arouses Republican passions of late:  It is about money.  It is about payback.  It is about the kind of back-scratching that used to be called by its right name -- political corruption.  (I've often wondered why, when reading media reports on campaign finance reform, we often see the word "abuses," but almost never see the word "corruption." If there is no corruption -- "dishonest exploitation of power for personal gain" -- then why the crying need for reform?)

Mr. Lewis, I appreciate that you have been courageous enough and principled enough to write articles critical of the Bush administration.  As I mentioned before, I admire your work, I really do, and have for a long time.  I am not trying to be a "squeaky wheel" here, or to parse your words.

I recognize that your column was an important contribution to the public dialog on these issues, and to our national discussion about the man who now squats in the nation's highest elective office.  I applaud that.

But since you chose to write about the man's motivations -- and about the content of his character as reflected in his administration's policies -- why not tell us the ugly truth?  You danced right up to the edge of that truth -- that Bush is a hypocrite who says one thing and does another -- and then danced away.

I think we both know that the problem with Bush's mind isn't that it is closed, or empty, or lazy, or small.  I think we both know that the problem with Bush's mind is that it has been bought -- as have his political policies.

"The Closed Mind," you say? I think not. Say, rather, "The Mercenary Mind."
YESTERDAY: WHAT TO SAY By Beth Albertson
RECENT: Jaded: Frequently Asked Questions II

SITE SEARCH
 
powered by FreeFind

JOIN E-MAIL LIST

powered by ListBot

SUPPORT THIS SITE

powered by PayPal

TABLE OF CONTENTS
JUNE, 2001 

  1    2    3    4    5    6    8
  9  14  15  16  18  19  20
21  22  23  25

ARCHIVES
MAY 2001      APRIL 2001
FEBRUARY - MARCH 2001 
precoup2k - JANUARY 2001

GENERAL ISSUE:
Shop The Coup Couture Mall

Shirts, Mugs & Mousepads
Buttons1  Buttons2 
Video

Freebies & Do-It-Yourself:

FREE PC WALLPAPER!
MORE FREE WALLPAPER!
BBBR Web Banners
KillCoup Label Art   
Flip Bush Label Art
Bumpersticker Art 
Mastheads 1   Mastheads 2

NEW RECRUITS

Site F.A.Q.
Resistance Fighter F.A.Q.
Greatest Hits of the BBBR
Mandatory Minimums

COMMUNICATIONS

Mail  The Diva, WebMistress
Get Low-Volume Newsletter
Visit     Newsletter Archives
eGroup      Radio Free BBBR
Failsafe eGroup BBBR Lives
Search         Search The Site

BBBR MARCHING ORDERS! 

CHECK LEGITGOV.ORG
VISIT THE ACTIVISM HQ

Actions/Marches/Protests:

NOW! RYOB Retrospective!
6-21 Bush Birmingham Info
6-22 Jeb in Daytona Beach
6-23
Freepers, Harris in SC
NEWS*NEWS*NEWS  HELP!
6-25 Bush in Detroit
6-27 Bush in NY? More Info
6-29/7-1 Phil. Convention
July 4th Bush in Philly
July 4th CA Energy Events
7-7 Bananas for a Monkey
7-7 Testicular B-Day Event!

HUMOR:  TROOP MORALE

Laugh at the Coup
How the Dunce Stole...
GOP Election Victory Guide
Dear Diva: Jokes Mail War!!   
The Hymnal 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
The Quotable GW Bush

ALLIED FORCES:

Graphic Links   Text Links
BBBR Web Banners

COUP2K INTELLIGENCE:

FL & TX Election Laws
Votes Not Counted
Racial Demographics
Global Perspectives

ENEMY DISINFORMATION:

Rove's Forgery
The Nixon Lie  GOP Lies
Commie Flag Supreme?
Bush Christian Testimony?
Gore Biblically Illiterate?
Gore Invented Internet?
No GOP Florida Recounts?
Contesting Results?

The BBBR 'Aide de Camp'

Internet Radio:  RADIOLEFT
Solidarity:        FRINGEFOLK
Web Links: LINK CRUSADER
Rants:            THE BARDGAL
Party:       DEMOCRATS.COM
Bush Recon:    BUSHWATCH
Media Recon:     BUZZFLASH
News: ONLINE J.,AM-PO-JO
Commentary:        BARTCOP
Think Tank: CM Helwig Inst
Activism:  ACT FOR CHANGE
Protests:             LEGIT GOV
March-East:   VOTERMARCH
March-West:     VOTERWEST
Reform:               FAIR VOTE
Music Parody:   BOOT NEWT
Greeting Cards:  TRUCARDS
Postcards:         SHRUBBISH
Dubya Diary:        MADKANE

RATE
The BBBR Resistance
as a Political Site

SUPPORT
Liberal Radio on the Net

SHOP Buttons T-Shirts, Mugs, Mousepads Videos

The ActivismHQ

E-Mail The Diva

TAKE
The Democrats.com
Voter Pledge

© 2000-2001 gorewon2000.net and coup2k.com. All rights reserved. Permission is given for individuals and non-profit web sites to copy and distribute articles provided herein in their original and unaltered form, provided attribution to this site is included. For-profit or print media seeking rights to publish or reprint content should send inquiries to thediva@coup2k.com
Fair Use Notice: This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Such material is made available in an effort to advance understanding of environmental, political, human rights, economic, democracy, scientific, and social justice issues, etc. It is believed this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 USC Section 107, the material is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving similar information for research and educational purposes.  See:  http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml

SURF
The Anti-Dubya WebRing
A Proud Member of
The Anti-Dubya Webring
Site Owned and Authored by
"The Diva"
List | Stats | Join | Rand
Prev | Skip Prev | Prev 5
Next | Skip Next | Next 5
Powered by RingSurf!